Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Think government is too big?


Well, it probably is.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

"Size of Government" as shown on your graph is not the same as "Government Spending", which is what you are really saying in your piece. Be direct and objective in your work, it's not that I don't agree with what the ultimate message is, it just comes off as a bit twisted when you label something one way, and verbalize it in a way that is not synonymous. Spending, as you know, can increase/decrease regardless of a change in the size of government.

Patrick R. Gibbons said...

There are many ways to measure the size of the government.

Overall spending, spending as a percentage of GDP, spending per capita, how many pages of regulation, how many civil servants.

How would you define it?

Anonymous said...

I think the most accurate and DIRECT way to define it is by those employed in government positions. If we're going to talk about spending, let's call it "government spending", if that's by a percentage of GDP or per capita, let's put that in the graph. If we're talking about size/amount of regulation, let's address it that way. It's just more objective that way... something this video clearly doesn't incorporate, as you mouth says one thing, while the graph shows a gross generalization for some form of visual support.