From today's editorial:
Unfortunately, while its goal is laudable, the editors at the Sun have no idea how to make it a reality.
*Per-pupil spending, adjusted for inflation. 1959-2007
But there is a better way. Just over 12 years ago, Florida enacted a series of free-market education reforms that changed its one-size-fits-all system. These changes included online schools, over 350 charter schools, corporate tuition tax credits and scholarships for students to leave failing schools. And Florida did this while increasing inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding by less than 70 percent of the national average and only $152 more than Nevada has since 1997. The results of reform speak for themselves.
And for those who are looking for alternatives to the one-size-fits-all education system we currently have, Patrick R. Gibbons, NPRI's education policy analyst, has a new study out on Virtual Schools and how online education can — and already is beginning to — change Nevada education.
One of the problems with education today is that it too often has a one-size-fits-all quality. The reality is that not all kids learn at the same pace or have the same academic interests. That is why on one hand it is encouraging to see the district do what it can to better tailor education to the needs of each child.Exactly — the one-size-fits-all public education system has been and is a disaster. Taking away choice and forcing children into a government-run, union monopoly of a school system has led to Nevada having one of the worst educational systems in the country. It's encouraging to see the Sun recognize the need for more variety in education and wanting unique educational choices for Nevada's unique children.
Unfortunately, while its goal is laudable, the editors at the Sun have no idea how to make it a reality.
Still, until we provide the schools with a better level of funding to accomplish this, students in Nevada won’t receive the education they deserve.Fact: In the last 50 years, Nevada's inflation-adjusted, per-pupil spending has nearly tripled. Educational achievement has been and remains stagnant.
But there is a better way. Just over 12 years ago, Florida enacted a series of free-market education reforms that changed its one-size-fits-all system. These changes included online schools, over 350 charter schools, corporate tuition tax credits and scholarships for students to leave failing schools. And Florida did this while increasing inflation-adjusted, per-pupil funding by less than 70 percent of the national average and only $152 more than Nevada has since 1997. The results of reform speak for themselves.
And for those who are looking for alternatives to the one-size-fits-all education system we currently have, Patrick R. Gibbons, NPRI's education policy analyst, has a new study out on Virtual Schools and how online education can — and already is beginning to — change Nevada education.
Posts
2 comments:
Throwing money at public education decade after decade has done nothing to reclaim education from the tyranny of schooling. Charter schools, and virtual charter schools, can be a partial solution but they are far from true free markets.
Meanwhile homeschooling has defied all of the "experts"; well-adjusted children who are socially active and academically successful. It is no wonder that charter schools might try to imitate homeschooling.
Mr. Gibbons' paper is well written and has several excellent recommendations. Unfortunately, though, he didn't consult with homeschool leaders (who have been active in Carson City since the 1990s) before recommending that virtual charter schools should be allowed to serve homeschool students.
To read our response to Mr. Gibbons, and why our support for his homeschool recommendation would be conditional, go to http://nevadahomeschoolnetwork.com/position-papers/
Besides our response you will find other papers there that may also be interesting.
-Frank Schnorbus
Nevada Homeschool Network, Chairman
My comment centers around the misnomer that "experts" or government officials are better at determining the best curriculum (with a set of standards) to meet every child's educational needs. Even at charter schools, whether virtual or brick & mortar, "someone" other than the parent is choosing the materials to be taught to the child.
We have found that parents who choose the curriculum for their own child are having the most success at educating their children. There is something to be said for the ability to adapt the material to the needs of the child on any given day. This is why we homeschool and why most homeschoolers choose NOT to participate in the public school; traditional, charter or virtual.
Post a Comment